| David in the News Arizona Republic, October 15, 2008: Hedges is divisive; Return Lujan, Sinema to Legislature in District 15 District 15 is in the heart of Phoenix, and in many respects represents the soul of the Valley. Diversity isn't just spoken here, it's many walks of life are largely embraced by longtime and new residents. In respecting differences — whether it be in age, ethnicity, sexual identity or income levels — neighbors and neighborhoods usually come together on issues that matter: - Education.
- Environment.
- Economy.
State Sen. Ken Cheuvront, an openly gay Democrat, faces no opposition. And for good reason. Cheuvront, a restaurant owner, has aptly represented the district in a professional manner. Reps. Kyrsten Sinema and David Lujan, both Democrats and both lawyers by trade, also are hoping to return to the state Legislature. They're being challenged by political newcomer Ed Hedges, a retired schoolteacher who's a Republican. “One of the things I love about District 15 is that it's incredibly diverse,” Sinema said. “Folks on the lower east side of the district have some real different characteristics than folks on the upper northwest side. But I think there are some things that all residents of District 15 have in common and that is concern about real bread-and-butter issues.” Sinema and Lujan are looking to play greater leadership roles in the state House of Representatives. Both, first elected in 2004, seem ready. “(Constituents) want to see reasonable policies, and they want us focusing on those reasonable policies and not getting distracted by the issues that tend to come up at the Legislature sometimes that maybe are not the most important issues in terms of making us strong for the future,” Lujan said. Sinema concurred. “We have some major, major issues facing our state,” she said. “Number one, first and foremost, we have to deal with our economic crisis. Arizona has been hit harder — Arizona government in particularly — proportionately speaking, than any other state in the country.” There must be cuts, she said. “There's no way we can increase taxes. Arizonans won't support it,” she said. At the same time, the cuts must be strategic, protecting education, transportation and government infrastructure to ensure a speedy recovery when the economy turns around. Lujan said one of his priorities will be tailoring the AIMS test to better reflect a mission for a better-educated workforce, just like in Phoenix Union School District, where he is board president. “One of the things I want to look at is to have that measurement based on how college-ready our students are,” he said. Lujan said the environment remains a key issue to constituents. “They want to make sure we're doing our jobs as stewards of Arizona to keep our beautiful state pristine for the future,” she said. Hedges, a 30-year resident of the district, seems well-intentioned, but misguided. He is a hard-liner on key issues such as immigration enforcement, education and budgets. “I'm for closing the borders. That's what a border is for, to separate one country from another,” he said, counting immigration as among his top issues. “We need to get rid of the people who are here illegally,” he said. “If the kids are here illegally, I don't think we ought to support their education,” he said. Lujan and Sinema support comprehensive immigration reform at the federal level, including secure borders, a guest worker program and a humanitarian approach to the illegal immigrants working and living here in a productive manner. It's strange for a public-school teacher (he taught at the now-defunct East High School) to support charter schools, vouchers and home schooling, but Hedges does, saying public schools waste money. And at a time when the state faces a $1 billion budget deficit, he even recommends a tax cut — without offering any solutions on how to make up for that lost revenue. In short, unlike the two Democrats, Hedges represents politics of division. The choice is clear and the decision easy in District 15: Return Sinema and Lujan to the state Legislature. Letter to the Editor in the Arizona Republic: Salute to Reps. Sinema and LujanMay. 15, 2008 12:00 AM Regarding the letter writer who called state Rep. Kyrsten Sinema naive for favoring community safety over harassment of immigrants, ("Rep. Sinema naive on law enforcement," Letters, Friday):
I want to offer my full support for Sinema and her colleague, Rep. David Lujan, also representing District 15.
We have the great good fortune in our district of not having to contact our legislators on every issue because they have demonstrated over and over that they have the best interests of citizens as their top priority. I can trust them to make humane choices, not to discriminate against minorities or other marginalized citizens, and to work for the protection of the environment and the highest good of all Arizonans.
If we could fill our Legislature with people like these two, Arizona would realize its full potential, leaving no one behind. - Ruth Zemek,Phoenix An article in the Arizona Capitol Times: Up Close with David Lujan
By Matt Bunk
Capitol Times
Friday, May 9, 2008
Rep. David Lujan is a scholarly sort. He isn’t big on rhetoric and soap-box speeches and rarely seeks the spotlight. But the second-term lawmaker isn’t necessarily shy either. Just bring up education funding or issues regarding polygamy in Arizona, and Lujan has plenty to say. He’s become one of the most outspoken advocates at the Capitol for enacting new laws to protect the women and children who flee from communities that embrace plural marriages and allow adults to “marry” children. And he’s a member of the Democratic bloc that fought to borrow and use accounting tricks to avoid larger cuts to education, health care and other state programs that were proposed to balance the 2008 budget. But Lujan, like many other first- and second-term Democrats, hasn’t been able to rally enough support to pass many of the bills he’s introduced, including a measure this year that aimed to change state law so that judges in child-custody battles would be compelled to refuse custody to a parent involved in child bigamy. Lujan, though, has vowed to try again next year. And he has been around the Capitol long enough to know that persistence pays off. Counting time as a page, an internship, a staff position in the Senate, a four-year assignment as an assistant attorney general and the past four years as a state representative, Lujan has been around the Capitol for 22 years. He’s up for re-election this year. And he’s got bigger plans after that — maybe even a run for Attorney General in 2010.
I got to know you through the bigamy bill that you worked on this year, so that’s a logical place to start. Can you tell me about that a bit and how you got involved with that issue?
I first became aware of the issue through my other job. I’m an attorney for a nonprofit agency called Defenders of Children. We help children who are victims of abuse. My job there is that I’m the staff attorney and I oversee a volunteer lawyer program. A number of years ago, we started getting cases out of Colorado City, where women and children were seeking to leave the polygamous sect up there. They came to our agency and as we started to help one and then another, they started to build a trust in us. As I was working on these cases, one of the things that occurred to me is that when they leave the polygamous communities one of the first things that they do is they file for custody. And the cases we were working on, the women who were leaving were losing custody to the polygamous fathers, or else they were going through long court battles having to get custody from them. I came up with the idea of introducing a law that would put a presumption in state law that if one of the parents is engaged in child bigamy or polygamy then they would not get custody. That’s how we introduced the bill last year. And then this year I narrowed it down to address just child bigamy and not polygamy.
Bring us up to date on that bill. Where’s it at now?
It’s been a bit of a bumpy road for the bill. It received unanimous support in the House Human Services Committee. And then it was held in the House Judiciary Committee. So, then I tried to revive it in the Senate, and I put it on as an amendment to a bill. It was heard in the Senate Public Services Committee and again received unanimous support. But then it got additionally assigned to the Senate Judiciary Committee, where it was held again. It doesn’t look like the bill’s going to move forward this session, but I’m going to keep trying next year.
And you had some help trying to revive the bill.
I actually had members from both parties who have helped me to keep the bill moving. I had Linda Gray, who has been very helpful. Judy Burges, Pete Hershberger, Andy Tobin. A number of Republican legislators have helped keep the bill moving. The bill really isn’t a partisan issue. It’s a bill to help kids. And I think most people down here support it.
Then why didn’t it pass? What was the trouble?
The opposition that’s been stated is that it’s not necessary. We already have laws on the books to address this issue. And that’s absolutely true. There already are laws on the books, but unfortunately they’re not working to help the women and children in Colorado City and other polygamous communities. And what I’m looking for is a law on the books that puts in a presumption that judges are not to give custody to fathers who are engaged in the practice of child bigamy, because the women and children who are scared to leave these polygamous communities need that extra assurance that the law is going to support them should they decide to leave. The bill has a provision that if the judge for some reason finds that it is appropriate to give custody to the parent who is engaged in child bigamy, then the judge would have to put those reasons in writing. So they have to come up with concrete reasons to establish why that parent should get custody.
What will you be focusing on for the duration of the session?
Being on the Education Committee in the House and also being the president of the Phoenix Union High School District School Board, education has always been an important issue to me. There are a couple of education issues that I’ve tried to focus on this year. One is English language learners and coming up with legislation that will resolve the lawsuit. I don’t think we’re there yet, but I’m going to continue to work until the end of this session. Even though we passed a bill to address it, I don’t think the funding that was in the bill was sufficient. So I’m going to see if we can come up with additional legislation until we sine die that will resolve that lawsuit. Another issue I’ve been working on this year is legislation to put a school nurse in every public school in the state, because I feel strongly that when schools have nurses it translates into students being in the classroom and better academic achievement. And it gives reassurance to parents that when they send their kids to school there will be a health-care professional there who will be looking after them should they get sick.
Doesn’t that bring up an appropriations issue that might be difficult this year?
Yeah, it does. I totally agree with people who say we shouldn’t put additional unfunded mandates on schools. Last year when I introduced the bill it had a $12 million appropriation. But I’m a realist. I know that in our times right now, there’s no way a bill like that’s going to get through with that size of an appropriation. This year, I reworked the bill to make it so that at least school districts would make an effort to see if they have the money somewhere in their current budget to pay for nurses. I really think that when school districts do the analysis, they will find that school nurses will pay for themselves. They will translate into more students being in attendance, which will result in better funding from the state. Issues like full-day kindergarten took years before they actually became a reality. So I think this is a similar issue. When people become more educated about the importance of having school nurses, more people, hopefully, will get on the bandwagon. And hopefully, someday it will be law in Arizona.
Given your focus on education, how do you feel about the ballot measure seeking to unify many of Arizona’s school districts? Will merging elementary, middle and high school districts into larger, unified districts improve education in Arizona?
Well, I’ll speak to the proposal as it affects the Phoenix Union High School District and the districts in Phoenix. Personally, I don’t think it will improve student achievement, which I think should be the bottom line. There are still a lot of unanswered questions in terms of, what are you going to do with districts that are consolidating that have different pay scales for example? How are you going to blend together the curriculum? I think there’s research out there that shows when you have smaller school districts, they tend to do a better job of focusing on the unique educational needs of their students. I think the system we have now actually works. We have small elementary school districts that can focus on the unique needs of the students in their neighborhoods. And you have a large high school district that can provide the resources you need at the high-school level, like drop-out programs and teen-pregnancy issues. I really think the system we have now, when you’re looking at student achievement, best addresses students’ needs.
The unification proposal calls for teachers to be paid at the same pay scale, regardless of whether they teach in an elementary school or in a high school. Should they be paid at the same level?
I think, yes, elementary school teachers should be paid at the level of high school teachers. I think the issue is going to be, if the redistricting passes, whether the state is going to come through and provide additional funding that the school districts are going to need to bring those salaries up to the high-school level. That’s one of the unresolved issues that I’m talking about. In the Phoenix Union High School District, our teachers are among the highest paid in the state, and in the elementary districts that would be combined into our district if this passes, the teachers are not the highest paid. It would take, I believe, a lot of additional funding to bring them up to that salary level. And I just don’t have much confidence that the state is going to provide this new mega-district with additional funding to bring the salaries up. Then my concern would be, instead of bringing the elementary school teachers’ salaries up, would we have to bring the high school teachers’ salaries down? That’s one of the many issues that, unfortunately, the Redistricting Commission has not provided answers for.
As for the 2008 budget that was passed recently, give me your opinion on what’s good about it and what’s bad.
I think the budget we passed was probably about the best solution that we could come up with at this point. I think it had a good mix of borrowing, budget tricks and fund sweeps that is probably the best we could do at this point. My biggest concern was to avoid cuts to programs for the vulnerable populations and funding for education. I think those areas should be hands off. I think the biggest challenge now is going to be 2009. The 2008 budget was the easy one. The 2009 budget is going to be a monster.
What are some of the primary programs and services that Democrats will try to protect in the coming months as the 2009 budget is negotiated and further cuts are expected?
I think as Democrats we’re going to protect funding for programs that are going to help the vulnerable — children, low-income families. We want to protect, as much as possible, public education. Health care. If there are going to be any cuts to education, hopefully they will be very minimal. Hopefully, there won’t be cuts to classrooms. I think those are areas that Democrats are going to try to protect as much as possible.
Should the state be taking some lessons from Corporate America when it comes to borrowing for infrastructure that will allow long-term growth? Or is it prudent to pull back and wait on the larger investments until the financial situation has improved?
I think there is a correlation between how Corporate America will bond to build for their future, and what the state should be doing. Although it’s probably not the most preferable way to go, I think when you are in difficult budget times as we are now, I think you do have to bond for school construction. Prior to getting elected to the Legislature, I was an assistant attorney general for four years and I represented the School Facilities Board. And I saw from that position the importance of keeping up with the growth of our schools. If we want to continue to grow our economy, we have to make sure to build public schools fast enough to keep up with that growth. I think bonding allows us to do that. One of the more shortsighted proposals I heard this year was to do a moratorium on school construction. I think when you are trying to stimulate the economy, the last thing you should be doing is halting school construction for a year or two. Who wants to move into a new housing development if there are no schools nearby for their kids?
You’re coming up for re-election this year. What’s the status of the campaign?
Rep. Kyrsten Sinema and I are going to run again as a team. We work well together, and I could not ask for a better seatmate. As of now, we do not have an opponent for the primary election. Two Republicans have filed to run against us in the general election.
What are your long-term plans?
I am thinking about running for attorney general in 2010. I worked as an assistant attorney general for four years and loved the office and gained great experience. I’ll see how the next year plays out and make a decision. |